Monday, February 13, 2023

Stir Within Yourselves a Greater Sensitivity to the Beautiful©

 My memory of this is more than a bit vague, but at some point in my education at BYU more than 60 years ago I became interested in the subject of “beauty.” I think there was some discussion–whether in a formal classroom setting or an informal discussion with friends, I do not know– some discussion of the aphorism “Truth is beauty and beauty is truth,” or maybe the other way around. Nonetheless, from that time forward the subject of beauty interested me and I tried to cultivate my taste to appreciate beauty in many forms. I wanted to understand the nature and importance of beauty beyond my own pleasure and satisfaction.  I even bought a volume from the Oxford series of Short Introductions.  It is Roger Scruton’s, Beauty: A Very Short Introduction. As helpful as it was, it did not satisfy my desire to understand more deeply the importance of beauty.

Last night, after lo these many years, I encountered what I was looking for.  It came out of two brief sentences in a talk President Gordon B. Hinckley, then First Counselor to Ezra Taft Benson, said in a talk to the women of the Church in October 1989.  His theme was “Rise to the Stature of the Divine Within You,”(1) and he offered the women of the Church three suggestions to help them do so.  First, he told them to get all the education they could and he spoke glowingly about education for several paragraphs.  In the course of those remarks he said the first thing that caught my attention about beauty:

In the process of educating your minds, stir within yourselves a greater sensitivity to the beautiful, the artistic....  [Emphasis mine.]

As I sat back and contemplated that I realized that is behind a large part of my own effort of continuing self-education. A description of those efforts will require at least one, if not more, chapters in my autobiography if I ever get around to it. A brief example must suffice here.  

When we came to Logan, Utah in 1979 where I was to teach Institute for the Church at the Institute adjacent to USU, several threads wove together at about the same time. Beyond reading Shakespeare’s “Julius Caesar” in middle school and the 1968 Zeffirelli movie “Romeo and Juliet,” I knew nothing about William Shakespeare or his plays, except I knew of his reputation as perhaps the greatest author in the English language. I was conscious of my ignorance of Shakespeare.  I had a huge “ignorance gap” and because of his reputation I felt an impelling need to fill that gap. One of my colleagues at the Institute was Canadian born and educated–Gary Bennett. I discovered in him a fellow book lover. He also loved and read Shakespeare. At the time PBS was running a series of the Bard’s plays and his example and enthusiasm set me to watching them. I also signed up for a Shakespeare class at USU which turned out to be one of the great intellectual experiences of my life. At the same time the Shakespeare Festival in Cedar City was beginning to blossom and we started to take advantage of that.  

I found Shakespeare difficult. Not only was much of his language archaic and almost incomprehensible, but it was also poetry, and as a genre it too proved to be very difficult for me. At USU we started with Hamlet and I actually read it eight times before I felt like I had a handle on what was going on, facilitated by a phenomenal teacher and class discussions. I created my own glossary because so many words were not in my vocabulary. To my dismay sometime later I discovered there was a glossary in the back of my textbook!  Ah, such is the life of the ignorant.  

I learned some very valuable things reading Hamlet eight times. I discovered that Shakespeare could be understood, if not conquered (he was a genius you know), with persistent effort and some good old “hard study time.”   My confidence grew; nay, it soared to the point I decided to read and study all thirty-eight of Sir William’s plays. Moreover, the effort was worth it! Not only was Shakespeare enriching my mind and my life, he was also useful to me. He frequently dealt with subjects and issues that were very pertinent to me as a teacher of religion. I found myself telling a story, quoting some lines, or using an example from one of the plays in my classes. It was enriching and fresh–and often very powerful.  

Second, and this is to the point of this essay: I found many parts of the poetry in Hamlet astonishingly beautiful and powerful language. Shakespeare’s skill amazed me. I fell in love with him. If I was conscious of beautiful language before that, it was only a faint consciousness, but this experience awakened a love for beautiful words that never died.  I have a file called “Picturesque Speech” which had its origins in Professor Wilson’s Shakespeare class at USU.  Understand.  It is not just the beauty of the linkage of certain words that impresses. Rather, the images, associations, meanings, and feelings those words powerfully invoked in the brain and heart at times nearly overwhelmed me. The beauty of the words themselves combined with their power was truly impressive, frequently astonishing. This is a phenomenon that does not end with the initial flood of ideas, sensations, and meaning. The richness and deepness of Shakespeare’s language and thought continues giving–provoking new thought, questions, insight, pleasure.

So, unintentionally I’ve been following President Hinckley’s advice, wonderful advice for all, to “stir within yourselves a greater sensitivity to the beautiful.”  

The second thing President Hinckley said in this talk came near the end.  It gave me the reason for “stirring” within myself that “greater sensitivity to the beautiful”. He said:

In the pioneering days of this church when men grubbed the sagebrush and broke the sod so that crops might be planted to sustain life, many a wife and mother planted a few flowers and a few fruit trees to add beauty and taste to the drabness of pioneer life. There are so many things that you can do. Beauty is a thing divine. The cultivation of it becomes an expression of the divine nature within you. [All forms of emphasis mine.](2)

Ah!  I love the positive prophetic perspective. It is simple, almost self-evident, and surely common sense to a Latter-day Saint. The trouble is, my mind is not the kind that readily sees the self-evident or the common sense, until someone with that skill points it out to me. Then I see it! And last night I saw and felt it with unusual impact. Of course, beauty is a divine thing. Surely God loves beauty and in his omniscience understands its nature, power, and purpose to the nth degree. Adam declared that the newly created world “is glorious and beautiful.” Artists, philosophers and others are fond of saying that the human form is the most beautiful of God’s creations. It seems now that President Hinckley said it, that it is common sense that God creates things of beauty, because it is his nature. It follows, therefore, when we stir up a greater sensitivity of the beautiful within and when we actually cultivate or create beauty, we are giving expression to the same divine nature within ourselves. How simple! How obvious! How true! How beautiful!

Lets think together again, soon.

Notes:

1.  Gordon B. Hinckley, “Rise to the Stature of the Divine within You,” Ensign (November 1989):94-98.  The indented quotations which follow are found on pages 97 and 98 respectively.  

2.  As a note of contrast, I’m presently reading a small book of poetry.  In two of them Ralph Waldo Emerson says two seemingly contradictory things.  In the first, titled “Each and All,”  he discusses the fading beauty of a wife: “The gay enchantment was undone— / A gentile wife, but fairy none.  Then I said, ‘I covet truth; / Beauty is unripe childhood’s cheat; I leave it behind with the games of youth.’” He seems to be saying in this case beauty is fleeting, a cheat, but “truth” is enduring.  However, in the short poem “The Rhodora” he extolls the beauty of the flower and exults: “Rhodora! If the sages ask thee why / This charm is wasted on the earth and sky, / Tell them, dear, that if eyes were made for seeing / Then Beauty is its own excuse for being.”  See, Roy J. Cook, comp., One Hundred and One Best Loved Poems, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1958, 5-6.

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

Evidence Sixty-Nine: Joseph Smith’s Snowflake in a Blizzard–D&C 35:14

101 Reasons Why I Believe Joseph Smith was a Prophet of God

Evidence Sixty-Nine:

Joseph Smith’s Snowflake in a Blizzard–D&C 35:14.© 

Updated: 27 January 2023

Some readers may not find today’s “evidence” overly compelling, but for me it fits into a larger pattern in the life and work of Joseph Smith that taken collectively is huge. This is like a snowflake in a blizzard–and the blizzard is the important issue. It is one we should attend to.  It is one that will continue to grow.  The blizzard is ongoing.

This has to do with an almost obscure passage–Doctrine and Covenants 35:14–and a specific phrase in the verse. For context and to make the point more clearly I quote a bit more of the passage beginning with verse 12 running through verse 14. I have italicized the phrase in the verse which is the subject of the discussion to follow.

12) And there are none that doeth good except those who are ready to receive the fulness of my gospel, which I have sent forth unto this generation. 13) Wherefore, I call upon the weak things of the world, those who are unlearned and despised, to thrash the nations by the power of my Spirit; 14) And their arm shall be my arm, and I will be their shield and their buckler; and I will gird up their loins, and they shall fight manfully for me; and their enemies shall be under their feet; and I will let fall the sword in their behalf, and by the fire of mine indignation will I preserve them.

According to this passage (and others in the Doctrine and Covenants) the spiritual condition of the world at the time of this revelation (December 1830) is poor.  So, in the Restoration the Lord calls upon the weak, unlearned, and despised, to “thrash the nations by the power of my Spirit.” These agents of the Lord, though not recognized as anything special have a special power by which they do their work–”the power of my Spirit.” Chief among these weak, unlearned, and despised, is Joseph Smith, God’s prophet.

Joseph Smith and others will have the arm of the Lord to be their arm. This is a metaphor teaching us that the strength of these servants will be the strength of the Lord. In addition, “I will be their shield and buckler.” The word buckler appears twelve times in the standard works; eleven of them are in the Old Testament and one is in D&C 35:14. That of itself is interesting and leads to the question why is it in the D&C.

There are three Hebrew words in the Old Testament from which we get the word buckler as a translation. A “buckler” is a small round shield. Among the dozen usages in the scriptures, half of them refer to the Lord as a buckler: 2 Sam. 22:31; Ps. 18:2, 30; 91:4; Prov. 2:7 and D&C 35:14.  The remainder, except one, refer to human beings wielding a buckler.  (1 Chr. 5:18; 12:8; Prov. 2:7; Jer. 46:3; Ezek. 23:24; and 26:8.) The exception is Ps. 35:2 which is a prayer for the Lord to take up shield and buckler.  

One other fact should be noted. Nearly half (5) of these references refer to both shield and buckler. One may wonder if this is not redundant. Probably not. It is likely this phrase is speaking of two different kinds of shields–large and small, and sometimes the buckler may refer, because of its association with the concept round, to something that surrounds one as a protection, such as a wall. In any case some from of this phrase is used four times in the Old Testament: Ps. 35:2; 91:4; Jer. 46:3; and Ezek. 23:24. And it is also in D&C 35:14.  

With this background lets explore D&C 35:14 by asking some questions about it.  My first thought was, “Did Joseph Smith know what a buckler was?” And my first answer was probably no, but upon further reflection I suspect it was likely a much more common term in his day than it is in ours. So it may not be unlikely that he would use such a term. 

A more serious issue is how is the phrase used conceptually when compared to the Old Testament.  In D&C 35:14 the metaphor regards strength and protection given to the Lord’s servants as they inaugurate the Restoration of the Gospel.  “And their arm shall be my arm and I will be their shield and their buckler....” This is totally consistent with its usage in the Old Testament.  Ps. 18:30 says, “As for God, his way is perfect: the word of the Lord is tried: he is a buckler to all those that trust in him.”  And Ps. 91:4: “He shall cover thee with his feathers, and under his wings shalt thou trust: his truth shall be thy shield and buckler.”

Here I confess a personal weakness–serious ignorance–compared to the Prophet Joseph.  I did not know what a buckler was until this week when I studied the issue with some friends. Or, if I once knew it, I long since forgot it. Yet Joseph Smith was only twenty-five years old when he penned D&C 35. Now it may be as I said earlier, that this terminology was more prevalent in his day than ours, and perhaps more familiar to him. But, I find it fascinating that this meaningful metaphor that is relatively obscure in the Old Testament, surfaces in the Doctrine Covenants in the correct context and with a meaning consistent with those few times it appears in relationship to God in the Old Testament. I suppose that one could say that either the concept was so prevalent that it was natural for him to use it, or he was expert in plagiarizing the Bible. Many critics are satisfied with either option. But it seems to me there is a third option and that is that the revelation was written under the influence of the power of the Spirit as the Lord promised in D&C 35.

Like I said earlier, this argument may be about a snowflake in a blizzard, but there is literally a blizzard of such examples. As one example, within the last decade a scholar at BYU has discovered that, not counting the “Sermon on the Mount” in 3 Nephi 12-14, there are as many as 600 other quotations of New Testament usage, large and small, interwoven in the text of the Book of Mormon.(1) That may trouble some, but there are good and sufficient reasons why this may be the case. Defending that issue, however, is not my purpose here. Taking a more positive approach, I maintain that this large number constitutes metaphorically a blizzard of examples of the exact thing we see in D&C 35:14, and in my mind can only be explained in one of two ways. Either Joseph Smith was a genius with the capacity and skills to remember such Biblical phrases and weave them into the narratives he produced, or he was translating by inspiration and receiving revelations in the same way.  I further confess that I find the genius hypothesis inadequate given Joseph Smith's age, the brief length of time it took to produce the Book of Mormon, and in a single draft.  I am making one more argument to add to many others of like kind, to the amazing complexity of the Book of Mormon. 

The blizzard is even more intense inside the Doctrine and Covenants itself, than in the Book of Mormon. Ongoing studies show that allusions to the KJV Bible in the Doctrine and Covenants are very high. In 1951 Ellis Rasmussen studied the subject relative to the revelations in the original Book of Commandments, just over 60. He found a median of 1.3 KJV parallels per verse in the Book of Commandments.(2)  In 1971 a follow-up study of sections 65 to 133 produced similar results with a median of 1.33 parallels and allusions per verse!(3) Erick Hunstman, commenting on these findings said, 

"In other words, for every two verses of the revelations, there are almost three phrases that closely parallel King James phrases. These parallels and echoes would not be apparent if they were not rendered in King James idiom, supporting one major argument for continuing to use the King James Bible in the Church today.  ... Indeed, ... a somewhat uniform idiom woven throughout the standard works helps realize the Savior's injunction that we should expound, and hence see, all the scriptures in one (3 Nephi 23:14)."(4) 

Moreover, Rasmussen found that these allusions and echoes were predominantly from the New Testament, but the Old Testament was not neglected. There are frequent allusions to Psalms, Genesis, Numbers, Exodus, and Jeremiah. "Disproportionate to their length are the number of references to Ezekiel, Daniel, Joel, Zechariah, and Malachi."(5) In addition to the extent of the quotations, allusions, and echoes, we add the fact that Rasmussen notes that only three passages were repeated with any frequency in the Book of Commandments!(6)

My prediction is that given time, ongoing study of the three books of scripture Joseph Smith produced, we will continue to uncover similar things and find them to be equally complex productions, thus the blizzard willl grow.

My personal opinion is that Joseph Smith was a religious and spiritual genius, but that does not account for the power that accompanies the scriptures he produced. The power which is “sharper than a two edged sword.” The power expressed in the metaphor, “the arm of the Lord.” The power of truth. The power of conversion and motivation to right living. That cannot be manufactured on call. It cannot be summoned up out of man’s brain alone. It comes, as D&C 35:14 says, through the Spirit.

Thank God for the Prophet Joseph and the power of a snowflake.

Lets think together again, soon.

Notes:  

1.  Nicholas J. Frederick, “The Book of Mormon and Its Redaction of the King James New Testament: A Further Evaluation of the Interaction between the New Testament and the Book of Mormon,” Journal of Book of Mormon Studies, 27 (2018): 44–87. See also a video of an earlier presentation on the same issue,  Nick Frederick, “‘Full of grace, mercy, and truth’: Exploring the Complexities of the Presence of the New Testament within the Book of Mormon,” The Interpreter Foundation/BYU Studies, 2015, at:https://archive.bookofmormoncentral.org/content/%E2%80%9Cfull-grace-mercy-and-truth%E2%80%9D-exploring-complexities-presence-new-testament-within-book

2.  Ellis T. Rasmussen, "Textual Parallels to the Doctrine and Covenants and Book of Commandments as Found in the Bible," master's thesis, Brigham Young University, 1951, 5.

3.  Lois Jean Smutz, "Textual Parallels to the Doctrine and Covenants (Sections 65-133) as Found in the Bible," master's thesis, Brigham Young University, 1971, 194.

4.  Erick D. Huntsman, "The King James Bible and the Doctrine and Covenants," in The King James Bible and the Restoration, edited by Kent. P. Jackson, 187.  Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, 2011.  See also these important studies on the same subject: D. Kelly Ogden, “Biblical Language and Imagery in the Doctrine and Covenants,” in Doctrine and Covenants: A Book of Answers, edited by Leon R. Hartshorn, Dennis A. Wright, and Craig J. Ostler, 169-87.  The 25th Sidney B. Sperry Symposium.  Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1996; and Lisa Olsen Tait, “Gathering the Lord’s Words into One: Biblical Intertextuality in the Doctrine and Covenants,” in You Shall Have My Word: Exploring the Text of the Doctrine and Covenants, edited by Scott C. Esplin, Richard D. Cowan, and Rachel Cope, 92-107. The 41st Sidney B. Sperry Symposium. Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 2012.

5.  Huntsman, "The King James Bible...," 187-88.

6.  Huntsman, "The King James Bible...," 188.



Monday, January 23, 2023

This Is the Man that Allegedly Leads the Republicans--The Main Reason I Left the Party

The following discussion, or parts of it, in one form or another has been floating around in my head for more than six years. It expresses so many reasons why I became an Independent.

Guest Charlie Sykes, on “Morning Joe,” hosted by Joe Scarborough, discussing Donald Trump’s “homily” at the funeral of a long-time supporter, Lynette "Diamond" Hardaway.  Trump did his typical rant and turned it into a political speech.  The panel considered it rude and narcissistic [Of course! He is constitutionally incapable of anything else.] 

***

"Just beyond bizarre, beyond rude, beyond anything that anyone would see in normal, polite, let me say decent society, and this is a guy that a lot of people want to be the next president of the United States again, and so on brand for him, too," said guest Charlie Sykes. "Look, this is what happens when you have a narcissistic sociopath give a homily at a funeral. It won't go well. Donald Trump has one subject, he has only one thing that he wants to talk about, and the crass indifference is just so burned in that he's not even aware of the fact that he, you know, is talking about other people that he had never met Silk. Of course, it's rude -- this is Donald Trump, and he's not going to change. But to your point, I continue to be amazed as you are."

"That's the interesting thing," Sykes added. "I always try to imagine the people who are watching this and going, 'Yes, I want that man to be a role model for my children, I want that man to be a symbol for America, I want that man to have his finger on the nuclear button again.' This has baffled me for six years. What is interesting as we get closer to 2024, Trump's behavior is, if anything, more erratic. Remember that there were people, you know, who talked themselves into believing, if he becomes becomes president, he'll become more normal, he'll grow into the job. It's exactly the opposite, and it appears to be accelerating, but again, as shocking as it is, no one should be surprised that Donald Trump goes to somebody's funeral, says he doesn't know the closest friend and talks about himself the whole time, well, because he's Donald Trump."(1)

Lets think together again, soon.

Notes:  

1.  Emphasis added.  You can watch the segment here: 

https://www.rawstory.com/trump-diamond-funeral/


Wednesday, January 18, 2023

I Resigned from the Republican Party and became an Independent.

 I want to make public that today I officially left the Republican Party and registered as an Independent.  Why?  Well, I’ll keep it brief.  For more than six years this country has suffered at the hands of Donald Trump.  He is a would be despot and tyrant.  He is willing to abandon Constitutional principles as he recently said.  He is equally deficient in four categories. It is difficult to tell which is worse, 1) his total lack of moral principles, 2) his monumental ignorance, 3) his insufferable arrogance, or 4) his desire to be a despot and a tyrant.  Combined, they produced the worst president in the nation’s history.  But the PARTY still cottons to him.  

And they (the party) showed they collectively possess the same four traits with the election of Kevin McCarthy as Speaker of the House, a Trump lackey, a man only a few steps behind in the categories mentioned above.  Moreover, to keep his slim majority vote, he refuses to take action on Representative George Santos–which to me is exhibit A that McCarthy and the party have the Trump deficiencies in good measure.

For these and other reasons, I feel (and my wife has done the same) that the Republican Party has sufficiently lost its moorings and abandoned moral government and good principles to the point that I am out.  They abandoned me, I have not abandoned them.

Lets think together again, soon.

Danel W. Bachman

Saturday, December 3, 2022

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF DONALD TRUMP NOW?

 Well, Kevin McCarthy, Lindsey Graham, Sean Hannity, Tucker Carlson, Mike Lee, and scores more of blind followers of the blind, what do you think of your boy now?

Donald Trump on Truth Social: “Do you throw the Presidential Election Results of 2020 OUT and declare the RIGHTFUL WINNER, or do you have a NEW ELECTION? A Massive Fraud of this type and magnitude allows for the termination of all rules, regulations, and articles, even those found in the Constitution.”

Holy smoke!

More than two years ago I told my wife, Donald Trump is a despot, a wannbe dictator, and I believe they will have to throw him out of the White House when he loses the election. It came mighty close to that and the more we learn it may have been even closer than we first thought.

He still believes he is the president. He goes by that title and has the presidential seal both on Truth Social.  

Today, he revealed exactly what I felt about him even before his election, during the end of his term, and even more since January 6. I’m crowing just a tad, because today vindicates every negative thought and feeling I have ever had about the man, though largely unspoken to anyone but my wife. 

However, today I’m happy! The leopard has at last shown his true spots–and one can only imagine how the above list, many other die-hard supporters, and my fellow Republicans are scrambling–some for the exits and others who will try to put a spin on it. What spin can they possibly put on it?  Only, that the man is a lunatic, completely out of touch with reality. He has sealed his fate as the Republican nominee as President in 2024, and to that I shout Hallelujah!!!  He is the true RINO!

Lets think together again, soon.


Monday, October 24, 2022

“Watch Ye and Pray, Lest Ye Enter Into Temptation”: A Neglected Form of Prayer©

In trying to improve my personal prayer life, I’ve been studying the teachings of Jesus about prayer in the New Testament. It has been very rewarding, enlightening, edifying, motivating, and at times troubling. This morning’s session was one of the latter. I’ve been working on the passage in Mark 14:36-39 about the Savior’s prayer in Gethsemane. Parallel versions are in Matthew 26:36-46 and Luke 22:39-46.  

Jesus has the disciples who are with him sit while he goes to pray. In Mark 13:34 he tells them to “tarry ye here, and watch.” In his prayer, he asks the Father if this “hour” might pass from him.  Inverse 39 of Matthew 26 he prays that “this cup may pass from me.” It seems evident that he is asking if he may be relieved from the suffering he is experiencing in Gethsemane. Yet, he tells his Father, “Nevertheless not what I will, but what thou wilt.”(Mk. 14:36) He returned to find the disciples sleeping and gives this instruction in verse 38:“Watch ye and pray, lest ye enter into temptation.” A similar injunction is in Mt. 26:41, but it is not in the Luke account. However, in Luke 21:36 there is something similar: “Watch ye therefore, and pray always, that ye may be accounted worthy to escape all these things that shall come to pass, and to stand before the Son of Man.” It is the “watch and pray, lest ye enter into temptation” that upon closer examination has come to trouble me a bit.

The same Greek word is translated watch in Mark and Matthew, and it basically means to “keep guard,” or be “vigilant” or to “watch,” according to Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance. There are other Greek words translated watch in the New Testament and it is used 29 times there.  Interestingly, another Greek word that is translated watch is accompanied by the injunction to be sober. (See 2 Tim. 4:5; and especially1 Peter 4:7.) This is because the Greek word means to abstain from wine or avoid intoxication.

A watch can refer to a sentry or a group of guards, who are on guard or watch at a military instillation, or in a community at night. In both Jewish and Roman culture the nights were divided up into watches, when a watch was on guard for a certain period of time during the night. So the question arises what are we to understand by the phrase be on guard, vigilant, and watchful and prayerful so that you will not enter into temptation? 

Some commentaries are helpful here, but I was particularly struck by several who note that the idea of the watch is often associated with the military and it is worthwhile to consider the implications of this “military figure.”  W. H. Aitken said no soldier likes watch duty. They prefer the excitement and danger of the battlefield to the “long weeks of patient vigilance” required of watch duty.  Another point he makes is that the military analogy is about war, and “it is just so in the spiritual war” we are engaged in. He goes on to say that the guards have to be vigilant against the double dangers of the night and of intoxication.

But intoxication is not my worry or the point of this blog. The point is that to watch implies that we are to expect the approach of an enemy. That includes an examination of possible points of attack. That is what you prepare for, and where you prepare. Aitken continues: 

We need to remember that we are in an enemy's land, and that unless we are constantly breathing the atmosphere of heaven, the atmosphere of earth, which is all that we have left, soon becomes poisonous, and must produce a sort of moral intoxication.(1) 

The famous early American preacher, Henry Ward Beecher agrees with Aitken:

It is here taken for granted that we are making a [military] campaign through life. The assumption all the way through is, that we are upon an enemy's ground, and that we are surrounded, or liable to be surrounded, with adversaries who will rush in upon us, and take us captive at unawares. We are commanded, therefore, to do as soldiers do, whether in fort or in camp — to be always vigilant, always prepared.”(2)

In 2018, President Dallin H. Oaks taught:

Opposition is part of the plan, and Satan’s most strenuous opposition is directed at whatever is most important to God’s plan. He seeks to destroy God’s work. His prime methods are to discredit the Savior and His divine authority, to erase the effects of the Atonement of Jesus Christ, to discourage repentance, to counterfeit revelation, and to contradict individual accountability. He also seeks to confuse gender, to distort marriage, and to discourage childbearing—especially by parents who will raise children in truth.(3)

Vigilance and watchfulness requires that we must make a thorough assessment of our present situation in life and of our weaknesses–the places we are vulnerable to attack from the Adversary. This is where the discomfort begins for me. I have tried to be vigilant about many things through my life, but I honestly have to admit there have been very few times when I have seriously sat down and conducted an introspective review of my weaknesses and then prayed for guidance to set in place a plan to deal with them and for the strength to follow the plan through to completion. Beecher said, 

Watchfulness requires that a man should be honest, and should know where he is, and where his danger is. Let others set their watch where they need it, and you set yours where you need it. Each man's watchfulness should be according to his temperament and constitution.”(4)

He added another helpful reminder:

Your excess of disposition, your strength of passion, and your temptableness are not the same as your neighbour's. Therefore it is quite foolish for you to watch as your neighbour watches. Every man must set his watch according to his own disposition, and know his own disposition better than anybody else knows it.(5)

My resolve is to be awake, alert, and vigilant, and to make such an assessment and consult God to give me the vision to see the dangers, to honestly see my most serious weaknesses, and in creating a strategy to deal with those that he wants me to bolster and fix now. Consider joining me in this endeavor to step to a higher and holier way.

Let’s think together again, soon.

Endnotes:

1.  W. H. Aitken, “Watchfulness,” in Biblical Illustrator, at Mark 14:38.  Biblical Illustrator is a multi-volume compilation of “illustrations” which are generally helpful quotations which  illuminate a particular Biblical passage. All citations from this source are available online at Biblehub.com, at Mark 14:38.  It is located in the list of commentaries under the acronym BI.

2.  Henry Ward Beecher, “Watching–A Military Figure,” in Biblical Illustrator, at Mark 14:38.

3.  Dallin H. Oaks, “Truth and the Plan,” Ensign (November 2018): 27.

4.  Beecher, “Advantage In Knowing One’s Weak Point,” in Biblical Illustrator, at Mark 14:38.

5.  Beecher, “Each to Guard Against His Temptations,” in Biblical Illustrator, at Mark 14:38.

Sunday, September 25, 2022

Bigotry and Prejudice Against The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saint Is Alive and Well in American Society and Its Colleges and Universities©

This will be brief, but I must speak out. Twice in the last year the supporters of teams in the PAC- 12 have given over to chanting the bigoted obscenity “F _ _ _  the Mormons” during football games against BYU. The history of persecution of the Latter-day Saints goes clear back to the beginnings of the Church in the early Nineteenth Century.  We have had two centuries to decide how to respond–mostly non-response, or taking it like a joke as with the play “The Book of Mormon.” These days we are often praised for our restraint. But the few articles I’ve read about these incidents, most of which call for an apology and even stricter measures, have all missed hitting directly a couple of important points to which I wish to call attention.

First, lets call a spade a spade. This is religious bigotry pure and simple. The academy prides itself upon leading the way through instruction and example of inclusion, diversity, and tolerance–except apparently for the Latter-day Saints. We seem to be one of the few groups in the U.S. against whom it is acceptable to publicly express religious prejudice and bigotry. It is not racism because we are not a race; it is not sexism either, though for certain reasons it may involve a near relative,(1) but it is religious prejudice and bigotry pure and simple. Freedom of expression sure, even blatantly offensive free expression for sure–all protected by our Constitution. I’m not calling for restrictions on such free expression–I am asking that we be clear about the nature of that expression. It is not reasoned debate or difference of opinion only. It is one of the most virulent types of free expression–castigating a minority group for its religious beliefs. It is expressed by the religiously prejudiced and bigoted in chants at a public sports event–where it nearly takes on a mob mentality.

Second, again lets call a spade a spade. This is a clear double standard in the academy and in our larger society. Imagine the outcry if this was shouted at the Catholics of Notre Dame, the Methodists of SMU, or Baylor Baptists. Doubtless it would be branded in the strongest terms as anti-Semitic if it was aimed at  “the Jews,” of Yeshiva University in New York.  (Do they even have a football team?  Probably not.)  It is difficult to imagine the outcry that would result if a PAC-12 crowd chanted this epithet at blacks, or gays, lesbians, bisexuals, queers, and transvestites. Such talk would not only be soundly and repeatedly condemned,  but very likely there would be calls for resignations and sanctions, maybe even reparations, and surely reformations of all types. Certainly such religious prejudice and bigotry should also be roundly condemned when aimed at the Latter-day Saints. I denounce this double standard and the religious bigotry it condones.

A significant segment of American society, including some of its colleges and universities, quietly harbor deep prejudice, bigotry and double standards toward The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.  It is a minority that is often considered a societal pariah in private speech and discussions. So it shouldn’t surprise us when it sometimes surfaces publicly in the classrooms and at sports events. If tolerated and not resisted, it will only grow and eventually turn really ugly.  It always does.

Let’s think together again, soon. 

Notes:

1.  An approach in this direction was made by Elder Russell M. Nelson as quoted by Neil L. Andersen: "President Russell M. Nelson has said: “There are those who label us [as] bigots, but the bigots are those who don’t allow us to feel as we feel but want us to allow them to feel as they feel. Our stand ultimately boils down to the law of chastity. The Ten Commandments are still valid. They’ve never been revoked. … It is not our prerogative to change laws that God has decreed” (in Dew, Insights from a Prophet’s Life, 212)

Neil L. Andersen, “The Eye of Faith,” Ensign (May 2019): 37, n. 17.